March 18, 2004
Even though I’m behind on posting once again, gotta post on this because I haven’t seen anyone else point here: Sony music download service to launch in June. I think my headline is more accurate.
Sony’s inability to sort out how to get its music foot in step with its technology foot has been discussed at length. This is but one example. Sony isn’t licensing to some Euro stores before it releases its Connect service. From the looks of this article, they might not even be adding other major labels to Connect’s catalog. Apparently, Sony hasn’t learned from Pressplay (which Sony invested in) and Musicnet that it’s advantageous to license widely, outsourcing storage and distribution to a better-equipped, dare I say smarter company.
But Sony likes to think of itself as a smart technology company. So smart, in fact, that it’s releasing music in the ATRAC3 format, wrapped in - you guessed it – Sony’s own DRM. It used to be called OpenMG X, but they must’ve thought the X was too silly, so it’s now just called Open Magic Gate (OpenMG). Maybe it’s name of the something you do in a video game, but I have no clue what makes this proprietary DRM “open” or “magic.”
“Gate”, I’ll give to them, because it sure does fence you in. Apparently, Sony is still interested in proving that this whole iPod thing is just a fad. ATRAC3 is the format for Sony’s MiniDisc players, and songs can only be transferred to “secure” Sony products. I’ve got some friends who love their MiniDisc players. Those friends also swear they can hear the difference betwen ATRAC and 128 kbps MP3s, and I’d say they’re just as loony as Sony. MiniDisc has never and will never be the wave of the music future. With all the great, tiny flash memory and hard drive portable MP3 players, I don’t see how building the business around these removable media players is worth it. (For the short run, the players should still do alright – I’m still buying a cheap MP3/CD player instead of an iPod. But the other players are going to come down in price soon enough. … Did I mention that Sony’s CD players only play MP3 and ATRAC as well? No AAC, OGG, WMA, etc.)
And be ready for Sony to move to the domestic market soon enough, bringing more incompatability fun with it. I thought Sony was working with Phillips on DRM that anyone could license - a Phillips executive even said: “The electronics industry recognizes that Microsoft is a formidable player, but consumer electronics makers do not want to become dependent on Microsoft. They need an interoperable and independent system, DRM is an accelerator which will boost digital sales of media, because it will convince media companies their content is protected. It should not be a competitive weapon.” Sony doesn’t seem to actually buy that. They’re trying to set the standard, and they want control over the devices.
Well good for Sony, but I ain’t going to buy its players, its music services, even its cameras (with proprietary Sony memory). To me, it’s a total waste. (See also some previous posts on this matter).