A Copyfighter’s Musings

Not sure if I missed it or this has just been poorly publicized, but have a look at Wippit‘s new model.  Parts of their website are so out of date (e.g., they no longer use P2P), that the service has often confused me.  At the least, I think they’ve licensed much more music than when Wippit 2.0 came out.

Here’s the pitch from the press release I received via email: for a $90 year-long subscription, you can download 60,000 MP3s – that’s about 667 songs per dollar, with no DRM.  Apparently, this catalog doesn’t grow in number, but it does change in composition – some songs will be added that are available to subscribers, but other songs will be subtracted so that the catalog is never more than 60,000.  At least, that’s what the FAQ suggests.  Still, if you download all 60k when you sign up, and then download all new additions, the catalog grows in effect.  Wippit also does offer DRM-wrapped songs for purchase to subscribers at a discount from the price offered to non-subscribers.

One might expect that Wippit would have no major or even significant independent content.  After all, the high license fees for this sort of service killed the original eMusic.  So one would expect this to be more like Garageband.com, with all niche or amateur content.

Not so, at least from my cursory observations.  You’re not going to get 60,000 of the most popular current content.  But I bet many (though not everyone) could find 9 albums that they otherwise would have been interested in getting. And as long as there are 90 bucks worth of albums worth getting, why not buy them through Wippit and acquire another ~59.9k tracks basically for free? While it doesn’t have the latest Britney album, Wippit does have the newest Franz Ferdinand and Interpol albums, for instance.  Popular independents like Dizzee Rascal and Royksopp are available, as are songs by independent artists I haven’t been able to find through Rhapsody or iTunes, like Soulwax and Rex the Dog.

This value-proposition would be a lot better if Wippit’s website were not such a phenomenal disaster.  The search tool is slow and clunky, and some songs are mislabelled (labelled as MP3 but actually only available as DRM-wrapped WMA).  There’s no recommendation system to help you figure out what else of the 60k you might like.

You could use other recommendation systems, though, to make some determinations.  In particular, people might use software like MoodLogic’s to sort through their music.

I report all this cautiously, since Wippit’s website can sometimes be quite confusing.  But the email they sent suggests that my assessment is accurate.

Filed by Derek Slater at 11:29 am under General news
Comments Off on Wippit Offers 60,000 MP3s for 90 Bucks