The Word on Lawyer Discipline: Maybe They DO Mean What They Say
Weakend Special
I bring this up because a tv commercial last night promised that “nothing works better” than the advertised product. Whenever I hear that claim, I wonder “do they mean that literally — would using nothing be better than using their product?” That thought merged two of my favorite hobbies: contemplating the lawyer discipline system and enjoying the oddities of the English language.
Below are some of the most important words in the realm of lawyer discipline and ethical responsibility, along with their various dictionary definitions. Were the words chosen to clarify or obscure? Which meaning is intended?
Code (from OneLook Dictionary Search Quick Definitions):
noun: a coding system used for transmitting messages requiring brevity or secrecy
noun: a set of rules or principles or laws especially written ones
verb: convert ordinary language into code
Rule (from OneLook Dictionary Search Quick Definitions):
noun: prescribed guide for conduct or action
noun: directions that define the way a game or sport is to be conducted
noun: dominance or power through legal authority
verb: exercise authority over
verb: be larger in number, quantity, or importance
Profession (from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia):
“A profession is a specialized work function within society. A profession is always held by a person, and it is generally that person’s way of generating income. Some historians believe that the foundation of modern civilization is division of labour into different professions, thus increasing the level of expertise held by professionals. ‘Profession’ is very often restricted to include only those occupations requiring extensive study, such as law, medicine, the Church or engineering. . . . Note that sociologists have been known to define “professionalism” as organised exclusivity along guild lines, much in the sense that George Bernard Shaw characterised all professions as “conspiracies against the laity”.
Sanction (from The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language: Fourth Edition. 2000, on bartleby.com):
noun: Authoritative permission or approval that makes a course of action valid.
noun: Support or encouragement, as from public opinion or established custom.
noun: A penalty, specified or in the form of moral pressure, that acts to ensure compliance or conformity.
verb: To give official authorization or approval to.
verb: To encourage or tolerate by indicating approval.
verb: To penalize, especially for violating a moral principle or international compact.
Oversight (from OneLook Dictionary Search Quick Definitions):
: a mistake resulting from inattention
noun
noun: an unintentional omission resulting from failure to notice something
noun: management by overseeing the performance or operation of a person or group
Responsible (from OneLook Dictionary Search Quick Definitions):
: being the agent or cause
adjective
adjective: worthy of or requiring responsibility or trust; or held accountable
adjective: having an acceptable credit rating
Discipline (from OneLook Dictionary Search Quick Definitions):
noun: training to improve strength or self-control
noun: the act of punishing
noun: the trait of being well behaved
noun: a system of rules of conduct or method of practice
noun: a branch of knowledge
self-reg·u·lat·ing (from Dictionary.com)
:
adjective
1. Regulating oneself or itself.
2. Regulating itself automatically.
Trust (from OneLook Dictionary Search Quick Definitions):
: the trait of trusting; of believing in the honesty and reliability of others
noun
noun: a consortium of companies formed to limit competition
verb: extend credit to
verb: have confidence or faith in
verb: expect with desire
Well, which meaning do they mean? Maybe “nothing is better” for clients than attorney self-regulation. Before I consider that complex problem, I need to engage in yet another of my favorite hobbies — napping. Then, perhaps a little bocce.
ethicalEsq?ethicalEsq?ethicalEsq?
Belated and blushing thanks to Robert Ambrogi, the godfather of lawsite reviewers, for his gracious (and insightful!) review of ethicalEsq?, on June 25, 2003, on his LawSites blog. Check it out and confirm your good sense in visiting this site regularly. It’s been four weeks since we launched ethicalEsq?, and this little client-oriented blawg has been averaging a surprising and heart-warming 300 page-hits a day. I’m humbled and grateful for the response, as are my sidekicks, Jack and Jackie Cliente.

The The Word on Lawyer Discipline: Maybe They DO Mean What They Say by David Giacalone, unless otherwise expressly stated, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License.