Banned Books Week Book Report
November 8th, 2010A few weeks ago, I wrote about my selected Banned Books Week reading, intending to report back here with the results. No, it hasn’t taken me *that long* to read all of the books, just that long to have a moment at the blog to summarize them.
- The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold: While this story is told from the novel perspective of a teenager after her death and provides an intriguing theory about what might happen to us after we die, it does include some graphic evil unsuitable for certain age groups and could challenge some religious beliefs.
- Lois Duncan’s Killing Mr. Griffin: What to do with young adults who act out, negatively influence others, and make bad decisions often puzzles adults. This tragic tale pushes those things past most people’s comfort zones. I’m not surprised some parents and teachers might be concerned about students learning about a plot to harm a strict teacher.
- Captain Underpants and the Big, Bad Battle of the Bionic Booger Boy Part 2: The Revenge of the Ridiculous Robo-Boogers from Dav Pilkey: While I found this story hilarious, some parents who try hard to teach children manners and respect for educators could find it an affront to their efforts. Also, the librarian in the book follows one of the terrible negative stereotypes of the nasty old lady librarian who wishes no one would touch her collection.
- The Color Purple from Alice Walker: With elements of racism, spousal and child abuse, sexual trauma and rape, drug and alcohol addiction, explicit sex, prison life, incredible dishonesty and cruelty, and more, I’m hard-pressed to think of another evil that could have been in this book. It could be a difficult read presenting so many tough issues, but Walker’s talent really does turn it into a beautiful story well worth the time because of the positive lessons, like the value of hope and strength of good family and friends, woven throughout.
And I recently re-read the last Harry Potter—the whole series of which has been targeted regularly because of concerns over violence, witchcraft, and magic.
In case you’re worried about me being too objective above, let me assure you I enjoyed all of the books and am quite happy to have read them. The freedom to read is a blessing I enjoy all too well. In these posts, I usually make observations about how viable claims of these books being unsuitable reading material, particularly for children or young adults, are. Sometimes, what ruffles people’s feathers isn’t always obvious to others. I can see why these books make people nervous.