No compensation when city takes private sewer system

Posted on January 26th, 2011 by Joseph William Singer.
Categories: Takings.

A court in Massachusetts has held that no compensation is due when a city takes a private sewer system. North Adams Apartments, L.P. v. City of North Adams, 2011 Mass. App. LEXIS 41 (App. Ct. 2011). The court held that the transfer of title from the private owner to the city caused the owner no pecuniary loss; indeed, it benefited the owner by transferring maintenance obligations from the owner to the city. The court also noted that developers frequently created sewer hook-ups and then voluntarily (and without compensation) sought to transfer title to the municipality. Although one might think that loss of control of the sewer connections would constitute a property loss, the court’s factual finding was that there was no reduction in fair market value of the property and no economic value to the land owner in retaining ownership of the sewer connections.

0 comments.