Middle East Peace Notes

Israel–Palestine Conflict

Archive for February, 2009

Why the 1967 borders work — or rather, the “1967+” borders– plus the large adjacent settlement blocs

Posted by middleeast on 8th February 2009

3 Shvat 5769, Saturday, February 7, 2009 23:02 IST

LETTERS

February 8: Why the 1967 borders work

On ‘67 borders Israel had virtually no demographic problems, no indigestible hostile lands, and no borderless and stateless paramilitaries.

Why the 1967 borders work

Sir, – Re “Why Israelis worry” (Editorial, January 26): Is it too late for reassurance on why Israel shouldn’t have any security worries about a return to her 1967 borders?

Almost no headlines concerning present difficult problems or “bad news” would be on the pages of The Jerusalem Post today if Israel was on those borders. She won her most legendary, decisive, lightning war from those 1967 borders. She almost lost another one (Yom Kippur) from her most expansive borders ever that included even the Sinai Peninsula.

On those ‘67 borders Israel had virtually no demographic problems, no indigestible hostile lands, and no borderless and stateless paramilitaries. She was much more secure than now.

Especially in an age of rockets (and nukes), security is not even mainly about borders, but about accepting neighborhoods.

JAMES ADLER
Cambridge, Massachusetts

Posted in Uncategorized | No Comments »

Barack Obama… and an eventual Israeli-Arab Prime Minister

Posted by middleeast on 6th February 2009

Friday, December 5, 2008 4:01 IST

 
… could be amazing

Sir, – In his book Old/New Land, Theodor Herzl envisioned an Arab prime
minister and a Jewish president. I believe Israel’s election of a first Arab
prime minister would be even more helpful and historic for Israel than
Barack Obama’s as president already promises to be for America. How could it
fail to transform Jewish-Arab, Israeli-Arab and even Israeli-Iranian
relations?

Picture the Arab and Muslim worlds suddenly having to confront an Arab
Muslim Israeli premier elected predominantly by Israeli Jews. Would it not
instantly boost recognition, respect, peace and security – to an
unimaginable degree?

And then picture the impact when the prime ministership peacefully reverted
to a Jew; and then, some day, to an Arab again. This realization of Herzl’s
vision would truly show up as a lie the Islamist and apartheid ideology of
al-Qaida and terrorists such as the Mumbai attackers.

A pipe-dream, maybe. At least, for now. But we all know what Herzl said
about dreams becoming reality. As Post editor David Horovitz urged during
the recent splendid concert visit to Israel of Sir Paul McCartney: Imagine.

 
JAMES ADLER
Cambridge, Massachusetts

Posted in Uncategorized | No Comments »

 
Protected by AkismetBlog with WordPress