You are viewing a read-only archive of the Blogs.Harvard network. Learn more.

f/k/a archives . . . real opinions & real haiku

May 23, 2005

luck or individual effort?

Filed under: pre-06-2006 — David Giacalone @ 7:51 pm

     potluck


Matt Miller asks whether “luck” or “individual effort” matters most “in determining

where people end up in life.”  He notes that both Democrats and Independents

overwhelming said luck in a survey he commissioned, while Republicans said it’s

effort.  (NYT, Taking Luck Seriously, May 21, 2005).  Miller states:


“Try too hard to wipe out the inequities spawned by luck, and you

banish luck’s societal benefits and go down the road of communism.

But harness a healthy awe for luck, and you expand the bounds of

empathy in ways that make a living wage for poor workers and great

schools for poor children national imperatives. What we’re led to is the

public agenda missing today, built around passionate commitments –

by both liberals and conservatives – to (1) equal opportunity and (2) a

minimally decent life, achieved in ways that harness market forces for

public purposes.”

dice  If Republicans won’t act on these moral imperatives, Miller thinks Democrats

should take luck seriously — making America more just by forging a victory

based on “values that can win.”   






horseflies’ and bees’
big lucky day…
blossom-filled temple

 


 



donning my umbrella-hat–
cherry blossoms portend
a lucky day

 



translated by David G. Lanoue 

 

tiny check  Your editor apologizes for all the webserver problems that have made

accessing f/k/a so difficult the past few days.  I’m afraid that no amount of effort on

my part will solve the problem.  Pray to the great Webmaster in the sky.


tiny check supplemental (midnight, May 24):  Sarni at Infernality chewed over and posted her Stick.

She has some interesting choices and — being into fanstasy literature — alternative  

Stick universes.  Talk about generation gap: not one of our choices matched.  Not one

of our genres, either.  I’m again surprised that so many people re-read books.  Has there

been a study about personalities that re-read books or watch particular movies or tv

episodes repeatedly (as adults reading for themselves, and not for children) as compared

to those who are one-off-ers?  [Note my Britsy idiom.]   I spent years recording hundreds

of movies (for personal use, of course) and have not watched even one of them in the

past five years.  I’m glad to see that Sarni feels no need for lugging a How-to-Survive-in-

the-Wilderness book.  That’s probably part of the basic curriculum in Aussie elementary

school — Walkabout Ed.   Stop over to Infernality and see Sarni’s Stick and shtick.  Thanks

for shaking and sharing your Stick, Ms. S!! 

 


“tinyredcheck”  I feel lucky today: two of my favorite haiku poets agreed over the

weekend to be Honored Guests here at f/k/a:  Tom Clausen of Ithaca, NY, and

Yu Chang of Schenectady, NY.   I will be formally introducing each of them this

week, but you’ve worked hard (or are just lucky) and deserve a double sneak

preview — with haiku and senryu by Tom and Yu from the latest issue of frogpond,

the Journal of the Haiku Society of America.


 

from Tom Clausen:



just oatmeal

the waitress says

“enjoy”

 

 

 

 




out of its reflecting pool

      the windblown

          fountain

 

 

 

 

from Yu Chang:

 






pumpkin patch

this one is big enough

for my son

 

 

 

 

taking turns

to stretch their necks

a pair of herons

 




“THNLogoF” “THNLogoG”

 




from dagosan  

 

 

last week of May

unpacking

the winter quilt

 

     [May 23, 2005]

 

 

No Comments

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Powered by WordPress